This article reviews the movie One Day (2011) by Lone Scherfig, in which architecture serves as an active element in Emma and Dexter’s emotional lives, shaping their movement, speech, and relationship. Streets, rooms, hillsides, lidos, and seafronts narrate their shifting social situations, confidence, and sorrow just as the story does.
Edinburgh
The roots of the story lie in Edinburgh, which is very significant through the streets of the city, the medieval old town and the well-planned new town. It represents a conflict between compression and openness, which parallels the couple’s uncertain beginning. Their student life is portrayed through small and porous interiors, open doors, friends drifting through, paper-thin walls with minimal privacy, where the physical proximity becomes unavoidable between them and the feeling of hesitation is intensified.
Their compressed social world is turned inside out by the scene at Arthur’s Seat, which takes them from closed bounds to an exposed hillside where the breathtaking city views are beneath them. The absence of boundaries and a vast horizon serves as an emotional balcony, a spatial metaphor for the possibilities that feel open widely even though their relationship is undefined.
Interiors and class
With the shift in the narrative to London, interior spaces begin to define class along with their personality, where Emma’s flats are cramped and filled with used furniture, which draws a strong contrast with Dexter’s spacious and curated homes and media studios. Emma’s spaces demand adaptation, where belongings are stacked wherever they fit in, and bodies cram around tables, whereas his surroundings provide expansive movement and casual chaos, which only money can tolerate.
Family homes with high ceilings, glass-fronted studios and luxury bars give Dexter the visual exposure but very little intimacy, where performance is encouraged over conversation. Emma’s little rooms make Dexter’s stature seem off, and she herself appears spatially diminished in his polished spaces. The architecture discreetly stages their disparity long before they identify it.
Streets and Encounters
Urban forms define the scenes of how they meet and miss each other. In the city of Edinburgh, narrow streets and staircases that force one-way walking, frequent pauses and near-collisions make the connection feel inevitable. But in the latter part, broad pavements and more readable grids of London make way for two individuals to drift apart in the middle of a stroll.
Station platforms, doors, and landings are examples of thresholds that function as spatial decision points where emotional decisions are brought into action, such as intervening, hesitation or turning away. The architectural coherence is maintained when the geography is squeezed through editing, which maintains the emotional logic of these paths by cutting from enclosed corners to other tight areas or from ascents to terraces.
Water Edges
Filmed at a modernist London lido, the outdoor swimming pool is a recurring element in the public architecture, which showcases Emma’s self-discipline and sensitivity through her frequent visits. In contrast to her confused, unquantifiable work of managing career and relationships, the strict geometry and lanes provide Emma with a visualised space where her efforts are visible and definite. Walking along the seafront promenades and quays in Britain and France promotes introspection, as the serene arrangement of railings, benches, and lampposts sets their personal turmoil against the stable horizon, which denies echoing their drama.
Paris
The film introduces the streets and apartments with measured facades, aligned balconies and soft daylight in Paris, which unfold Emma’s mature sense of herself. Rooms and interiors in these scenes are neither cramped nor grand, which perfectly aligns with her emotional and intellectual self. Dexter is more fragmented, and these same composed spaces appear quietly judgmental: the balance and consistency of Parisian streets indicate how unsettled he is. As he was portrayed for all glassy bars and lavish rooms initially, he now goes through the ordered stone halls like someone out of sync with the placid aloofness of the city.
Returns and Built Memory
Finally, the film revolves around revisiting the same date over different years, thereby transforming the locations into reservoirs of layered time. Hills, staircases, and nooks come to hold the past incarnations of Emma and Dexter like hazy layers, reinforcing the passage of time.
Architecture ages more slowly than bodies; thus, a familiar staircase or skyline becomes a standard against which altered posture, expression and closeness are measured. When the scenes return to the key sites, spaces get imprinted in memory: a wall that was leaned upon in flirtation now supports solitary anguish, and a bed shifts from a promise to emptiness without transition in the position.
The film, “One Day”, is not just a romance set across Europe. It is a reflection of how our emotional lives are subtly shaped by the architecture around us: how a room’s size may foster candour or evasion, how a street’s layout can induce interactions or voids, and how visiting the same location years later compels us to acknowledge the differences between our former and current selves.
References:
Focus Features 2019, The wide world of One Day, Focus Features, viewed 1 December 2025,
https://www.focusfeatures.com/article/one-day_travel-locales
IMDb 2025, One Day (2011), IMDb, viewed 1 December 2025,
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1563738/
Film Edinburgh 2024, One Day – Filmed here, Film Edinburgh, viewed 1 December 2025,
https://www.filmedinburgh.org/Filmed-Here/One-Day
Almost Ginger 2023, One Day filming locations in Edinburgh: Full list + map!, Almost Ginger, 4 August, viewed 1 December 2025,
https://almostginger.com/one-day-filming-locations/
NPR 2011, One couple, “One Day”, many years, many tears, NPR, 18 August, viewed 1 December 2025,
https://www.npr.org/2011/08/18/139639585/one-couple-one-day-many-years-many-tears
Scott, A O 2011, ‘One Day, directed by Lone Scherfig – Review’, The New York Times, 19 August, viewed 1 December 2025,
https://www.nytimes.com/2011/08/19/movies/one-day-directed-by-lone-scherfig-review.html
Den of Geek 2023, One Day review, Den of Geek, 9 October, viewed 1 December 2025,
https://www.denofgeek.com/movies/one-day-review/
Slate 2024, One Day: The 2011 movie’s director doesn’t regret that ending, Slate, 14 February, viewed 1 December 2025,
https://slate.com/culture/2024/02/one-day-movie-2011-anne-hathaway-lone-scherfig-netflix-show.html
Wikipedia 2010, One Day (2011 film), Wikipedia, 4 August, viewed 1 December 2025,
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One_Day_(2011_film)
YouTube 2025, Walking through the movies: Edinburgh’s 7 best filming locations (video), YouTube, 29 May, viewed 1 December 2025,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AdFUJyajdcc
Cairns, G 2011, [Article on film, space and architecture], in Sixth International DEFSA Conference Proceedings, Design Education Forum of Southern Africa, viewed 1 December 2025,
https://www.defsa.org.za/sites/default/files/downloads/2011conference/Cairns.pdf
